Sunday, September 4, 2011

Thu 1 Sep 2011 - Equus

The problem with the Equus last night lay with the two leads. It was the kind of acting that I had been fiercely steering my “All My Sons” cast away from. The actor playing Dysart had great facility and fluency, but it was all words, words, words. He was energetic, enthusiastic and sprightly in movement – never was there ever a sense that here was a man who was over-cerebral, calcified and bloodless. The blood was all on and in Alan Strang. However, the young actor who played Strang did his best, but you never believed that he was capable of blinding an ant, much less a horse.

And I don’t think the audience got hit by the ending as it should. Strang suffers a hysterical breakdown at the end, his recounting and re-living of the events of the blinding being both the climax as well as the breaking point. He is reduced to a sobbing and broken mess. Like after blood-letting, he is supposedly on his way to being ‘cured’. He has been punctured and his demons have been let out. But we didn’t see the crucial attack on the horses – it was artfully re-done so that he stood alone wielding a knife and slashing at the air. He then collapses and Dysart cradles him while delivering his final speech. I think the audience would have wondered: what was that all about?

When Leslie and I were discussing it, I didn’t want to give my response first, fearing a negative bias on my part. I was keen to hear what Leslie felt. It was when she said she felt no connection with either Dysart or the interaction between Dysart and Strang that I put in my bit as to why this was so. Leslie’s comments on our production 10 years ago renewed my faith that it had been a good production. It was so hard to judge as I was IN the show, not watching it. I wanted to see our horses but my back was always turned to them. From all accounts, our horses were magnificent. And Subra as Nugget was magnificent – the noble horse-god in Strang’s eyes.

And Mrs Strang. Instead of the repressed, repressive and oppressive woman, we saw a smart person clad in jeans/slacks and smart casual tops. This was the part that I didn’t get. It’s all in the script, isn't it?

Yes the set was effective.

Yes, there was the requisite nude scene. For Strang, full frontal and extended (I mean, the scene); for the girl, bra-less. Leslie wondered if the audience would have flocked to the show without this. Hard to tell, but in my theatre-going youth in Melbourne, I remember I did! But now, in my sagacious phase of life, I found it all a terrible distraction (sorry Shaffer). It distracted from the important text that was being spun out right at that moment.

And maybe the nude scene would have been better in the scene when he takes Nugget out for secret rides at night – the at oneness with nature, the at oneness with the horse, the spiritual union with all that is liberating in the universe. This would have been the right place for it (sorry Shaffer).

But then again, we didn’t have it in our production, and nobody missed the Meaning or the sensory thrill felt by Strang that it was meant to convey. So maybe it added nothing to the play at all. Sorry Shaffer, looks like you were wrong.

No comments:

Post a Comment