A very successful evening on Sunday 29 July for the fundraising dinner at the Tanglin Club. My email to the cast this morning sums it up best:
I was able to watch the show as just another member of the audience, sitting back and allowing the performance to work on me. And the following are my thoughts:
Eleanor – Without you, there would have been no Emily. Everyone else in the cast could be less than fully satisfactory and we would still have show. But not if the Emily was less than satisfactory. Everything was in the music and lyrics, the songs, and this was where you rose to the occasion. And you delivered what I consider to be the single most powerful moment in the script – Emily’s monstrous denunciation of Richard on her arrival in England. Musically, abetted by August, this moment was truly monstrous, and it made Richard’s subsequent suicide believable. It made the suicide a key point in Emily’s tragedy, rather than a sad aside in her life.
Dominic – You have acquired now a certain stage presence that makes all the difference. You stand there, script in hand, and the audience notices you. Even with the mousy Richard, the audience HAS to notice you. That is the demand of theatre. A mousy actor would be unsuccessful as a mousy Richard. And more, when the moment called for a simple smile as in “Welcome to Emerald Hill”, you were able to radiate. And “Riding High”s impact was exactly as how we dreamed it would be.
Jameson – Your training and experience allowed you to pull the rabbit out of the hat. Your actor’s intentions were clear and you executed them, with only occasional moments here and there where you didn’t strike always strike the right note dramatically. You had not allowed sufficient time for these moments to stew and cook properly. But overall, you had a Kheong. And your never-done-before death scene with Farah was authentic and therefore moving – you managed to abet each other there. You had a Kheong, and a Charlie. I thought the Charlie was spot on.
Farah – I picked you for this show because I knew you would be visually a very strong presence in a static concert performance. And you were what I had anticipated. You were a radiant Diana, and the audience could understand why Kheong would fall for her – there was something sweet and happy about your Diana that was a contrast to the harridan Emily. And you acted all the way, the way you got up, the way you sat down, the way you sat forlornly at Kheong’s rejection. The way you sang at Kheong’s hospital bedside was very effective, and your Manis Manis moment finally came alive the way the creators imagined it. And one more thing: the microphone demonstrated your phonogenic voice, which only truly came alive in front of it. But I already knew all this, because I had experienced it before.
Alin – As expected, you were a formidable Twa Kor in voice and manner, and you and Cynthia made a great pair in Bini Macham Berlian. In both of you, there was character but there was also charm, a requisite in a musical of this type. You executed Doris the way Stella had imagined it, catching the hesitancy and defensiveness in your meeting with Emily. You created another differentiated cameo as Mother in law, and I didn’t realize it then, but you were the only member of the female cast whose voice could have carried in that contralto range for singing MIL’s lines! So there was vocal differentiation as well in your 3 roles. This time, I can’t claim credit for finding the match between actor and role because I gave you the role of MIL without realizing the music’s needs – it was accidental.
Cynthia – There was a contrast in your Jee Kor, enough to ensure that she wasn’t a duplicate of Twa Kor. Your Jee Kor was the sweeter of the two sisters, the slighly more charming of the pair. I noticed the way you walked back to your seat to sit down, all in character, after Bini Macham Berlian. I had actually picked you more for your musicality initially, because I needed someone who was rock-solid to anchor the ensemble, somebody who was more singer than actor - to be pitch perfect, rhythmically perfect all the time. And in these departments, you were absolutely rock solid.
Aaron – I picked you because I knew about your inborn dramatic instincts. With 6 rehearsals planned, I needed even in a smallish role someone who didn’t require to be coached in detail on the acting side. You delivered on the night (though you gave me concern just a few hours before!), and in your solo song, you caught the wistfulness in your singing and in your stage manner, without hamming. There was a simplicity and truth in your performance, and this is what I mean about your inborn dramatic instincts. Your unusual bass-baritone voice also provided a needed contrast on stage. Two years ago, when I first auditioned you, it was your voice that stood out, in a sea of young male auditionees singing in the current faddish high tenor pop range.
August – Your playing made you in effect the 8th cast member of the show, so integral were you to the unfolding of the drama on stage, the pacing, the dynamics, the ebb and flow of it all. This is a different thing entirely from your talents as a music arranger or musician. Your contribution was obvious in all the songs, but was most noticeable in the long Mother and Child sequence where it was obvious that the music was driving the drama, not following it.
Thank you all. I trust you find the above feedback useful, because I often wish the people who direct me would be more forthcoming in their feedback. Most directors give you notes, but not feedback of the type above.
Finally, may I share my own actor’s advice with you all: Always allow preparation time for the preparation of your role. On opening night, your role must sit on you like comfortable old clothes even though the role is very new. As an actor, I am ready in my role at the halfway mark of the rehearsal process, and my opening night performance takes place one week before opening night. Therefore, on the opening night, I am giving my 7th night performance. On opening night, I am therefore totally comfortable, developed, nuanced in emotion, voice, gesture, movement. My target? I aim never to strike a false note, an out-of-character note, in my acting. I could see that the great majority of you didn’t see it the way I see it. Yes, you did deliver on the night, but that is not what it’s all about. You delivered, on the night, an opening night performance. However perfectly executed it might have been, it would still be an opening night performance.
I am particularly sharing this with all of you whom I personally mentored, whose start in theatre was with me (Dominic, Farah, Cynthia, Aaron), because I feel that my final parting lesson for you all needs to be given. I have not completed my job if I have failed to get you to understand this.
Hope to catch you all another time soon.